?

Log in

Previous Entry | Next Entry

On Politics Being Personal

Trigger warning for discussion of sexism, sexual assault, and racism.


"The list of grievances for MRAs is long. It includes the elevated rate of suicide for men, educational discrimination against boys, economic and workplace conditions for men, violence against men, false rape reporting, fathers’ rights in custody battles, rates of male imprisonment and prison conditions, and the horrors of war. Many of these issues deserve a thoughtful response and the force of an organized movement for address them. It’s too bad that’s not what men’s rights activists are offering."

A Good Men's Rights Movement is Hard to Find by Jaclyn Friedman.

Whilst reading about Men's Rights activism I have repeatedly come across the idea that people who fight against the sexual abuse of women do so while condoning or disregarding the sexual abuse of men. (I thought I should provide a couple of examples. a disagreement with seanan_mcguire's declaration that she will not have her character Toby Daye raped, and a discussion of a set of photographs of men holding quotations from those who raped them (TW: features the photos). I figured that rather than just saying "But that's not true!" I would post some links to resources (some of which I found in the above article) whose existence demonstrates that this idea isn't true, that we oppose sexual assault being perpetrated upon anyone. The photos linked above come from Project Unbreakable, Grace Brown's series of photographs she's taken of survivors of sexual assault holding a poster with a quote from their attacker. I've written about it here before.

'The Rape of Men' by Will Storr, "reveals how male rape is endemic in many of the world's conflicts."

http://www.justdetention.org/ is "a human rights organization that seeks to end sexual abuse in all forms of detention."

http://malesurvivor.org/ is an organization focused on "overcoming sexual victimization of boys and men"

http://servicewomen.org/ works to end sexual assault and sexual harassment in the US Military, directed against anyone.

I know there are more resources out there, and I'll keep signal-boosting them.

Last but not least, this year's "don't dress in costumes based on slanderous stereotypes of cultures" campaign from Ohio U's Students Teaching ABout Racism In Society "features side-eye" as a friend of mine put it.







Comments

( 8 comments — Leave a comment )
vassilissa
Oct. 26th, 2013 03:43 pm (UTC)
Made the mistake of reading the link disputing Seanan McGuire. Note that a number of the characters that never happened to DID have that happen to them. Did you know that Marge Simpson was never pregnant? Or that JOSS FUCKING WHEDON never used a pregnancy plot or a rape plot to advance his female characters' development?

Then I read Seanan's article, and omg. D: When? Finally? Clearly someone was really looking forward to that part.
browngirl
Oct. 26th, 2013 03:54 pm (UTC)
Yeah, that post was an entertaining example of several phenomena, not least that when someone says, "X concept is often linked to Y group, and that's a problem which needs to be addressed", someone else cites a list of members of Y group who have not been linked to X concept as a reasn why There Is No Problem You're Just Overreacting. I saw that happen a lot in the comments to the excellent article "The Rape of James Bond". To make matters that much more so, as you pointed out here, such refutational lists are often inaccurate.

seanan_mcguire's article was excellent, but yeah, I share with you and umpteen pages of commenters the sheer horror that someone said such a thing to the author, and upbraided her when she replied "no". I mean, as a fanfic writer I've written about sexual assault, but not because any character "needs" to be raped (omg UGH NO) and I'd never say that to the author (OMG ugh NO).

I hope this makes sense, yellination is happening. (hence edits) (also, dammit autocorrect stop 'fixing' usernames)

Edited at 2013-10-26 03:57 pm (UTC)
johnpalmer
Nov. 1st, 2013 02:56 pm (UTC)
Herm. Marge Simpson never had pregnancy used as a character growth/change device, which is a fair point. But then *MARGE SIMPSON IS LITERALLY AND FIGURATIVELY A TWO DIMENSIONAL CHARACTER*. (ahem. Sorry.) Throwing her out as an example is such idiotic cherrypicking that I'd blush to realize I'd *thought* of including her.

I loved the last bit. No one has used "she was asking for it" as a rape defense. Yeah, no one ever said "look, you can't say that the sex wasn't consensual, or at least that a reasonable person wouldn't assume it was!" to defend against rape.

(Yes, I know, he wants to pretend "asking for it" means something other than, you know, asking for it (lack of quotes intentional), as if that wasn't the entire *point* of the "asking for it" defense - that it was (or probably surely seemed to be) consensual.)
achinhibitor
Oct. 27th, 2013 01:05 pm (UTC)
All of that is good. Though I had a stray thought whose ultimate resolution I do not see.

Make one of those posters with the image of an over-the-top dressed rapper, or perhaps one of the more flamboyant Kid Rock images. Are such people flaunting stereotypes, expressing themselves authentically, or what? Does it matter that they make lots of money looking so ridiculous?
browngirl
Oct. 27th, 2013 01:58 pm (UTC)
Well, the key is in the caption: "When this is how the world sees you, it's just not funny." No one would look at you and see Kid Rock, but a hell of a lot of people look at me and see the stupid hotsy-totsy image in jungle print which the girl in blackface has dressed up as. That's the difference.
(Deleted comment)
browngirl
Oct. 27th, 2013 01:59 pm (UTC)
Oh goodness, you're welcome. :) I do what I can to promote useful information.
poltr1
Oct. 29th, 2013 05:20 am (UTC)
In my judgment, mens' rights organizations are trying to swing the pendulum back in their direction, as if it were the 1950s all over again.

There needs to be a balance.

I'm happy that the mens' organization -- The Mankind Project -- doesn't spout these beliefs. Instead, we focus on helping each other become better men.
( 8 comments — Leave a comment )

Latest Month

June 2017
S M T W T F S
    123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930 
Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Lilia Ahner